Expansion woes for Retailers

I have admired the way Mahindra Retail has built a respectable business over the past few years, ever since the launch of “Mom & Me” Stores in 2009 which sell mothercare and babycare products. In a short period of time, the company had built a massive network of 115 stores ( as on this date) spread over 10,000 – 15000 sft. primarily at residential locations in metros and mini-metro cities. The Brand has earned the respect and spending of thousands of customers for their friendly staff, wide assortment and excellent service at their stores. The market size for this category is about INR 40,000 crores and the organized segment accounts for less than 5% with small mom-and-pop stores taking away most of the business. Apart from Mom & Me, there is no other respectable national chain of repute in India other than Mothercare, which is operated in India by Shoppers Stop and kids wear sections of reputed Retail Brands such as United Colors of Benetton, Tommy Hilfiger, Zara, to name a few. Therefore, they had a massive opportunity to quickly garner market share within the organized space. Just when things were going good, they launched a new division in the name and style of “Beanstalk” which focused on Toys, Puzzles, Games, etc. While many of the Beanstalk showrooms were part of the Mom & Me stores or located adjacent to them, many were standalone locations in pitiable environments. While Hamleys caters to the upper end of this market, Beanstalk tried to bridge the gap competing with the neighbourhood stores.

Although scaling up evens out Fixed costs in the Retail business in the long term, it also proves to be a massive cost burden in the short-medium term. I guess, that’s exactly what happened to Mahindra Retail. Their swanky office in South Bangalore is spread over three floors, houses hundreds of employees and over a dozen senior recruits – from merchandising to operations to marketing and business development. While there were plans to reach a billion dollars in sales, the company could manage not more than 20% of that figure in the fourth year of its operation and was losing over INR 50 Crores every year. Obviously, the plot was lost somewhere and half a dozen senior guys moved out of the company over the past few months. The company also plans to shut atleast 10 stores in the near short term which are making heavy loses. As reported in The Mint newspaper, Mahindra Retail declined to comment on the specifics of the store closures but chief executive K. Venkataraman said in an emailed statement, “Retail Industry is cutting costs as a rule everywhere, and Mahindra Retail too does where we deem fit. Closure of non-performing stores, and some churn in management are unavoidable realities of the business, much as new stores and new management replace the lost ones.”

The biggest bane of Retailing in India is the Real Estate and Manpower costs which is what plaguing most of the Retailers. Ideally, the Rent to Sales ratio should be not more than 15-18% in the second year of operation but that is not to be. Manpower costs are enormous in the beginning of the business as most Retail companies believe in showing off a massive strength of show in its teams. I am aware of so many case studies from the west where frugal HR costs are the norm. But in India, we have cultivated a culture of large teams, each level overseeing the other and hence so many layers and levels. While Mom & Me is essentially present only on High Streets, a very smart strategy I would say (to keep Maintenance and allied costs lower which are a big takeaway in Malls and Shopping Centres), the unrealistic High Street Rentals are not helping Retailers much.

Mom & Me is not just a retail store – it has already cultivated a calibrated relationship with its customers during its short tenure and I am sure the company would tide over the current circumstances quite well. The challenge is whether to expand further to leverage fixed costs or to build efficiency with the current set-up. Would make for a great case study in years to come.

Car Care at its best

I pass through this outlet almost everyday but have always been on a rush. This time around, I stopped by and experienced first hand what they have to offer. I am referring to the 3M Car Care outlets which have sprung up across the country quietly but drawing attention from car enthusiasts and those who love to maintain their cars spic and span. These outlets are franchised and are managed by capable entrepreneurs who have an inclination towards the automotive business and customer service. Spread between 1,500 sft – 4,000 sft covering three different business models, these stores provide complete car care which include the following;

• Car Detailing
• Interiors / Exteriors
• Corrosion Treatment
• Films for sun protection
• Car Care products Retailing
• Car Graphics
• Customer Engagement
• DIY Bays

I was warmly welcomed by a service staff who knew his subject well – he explained the different packages they offered and justified why they were expensive. There were already two vehicles which were undergoing treatment – a Mercedes S Class and a Renault Duster. I asked him how is the business doing and he gave a smile, meaning things were doing quite well. Location was not totally a disaster though. It is located on the Beach Road, close to the iconic Light House (in Chennai). Although I felt it could have been located more strategically. Another gentleman walked over to me shortly and started interacting. Introducing himself as Vijay, he informed that he was the Franchisee Owner of the store. He explained in great depth his interest in automobiles, cars and bikes alike and his love for taking good care of them. According to him, the investment on the store including security deposit is around a crore (though I felt it was quite high) and the monthly business was about 15 lakhs with a margin of 35% on Sales.

The customer lounge is powered by lighting wifi and one can use the facility while the car is being spruced up. Customers have written their compliments and feedback on Post-Its, which is incidentally one of the most iconic products of 3M.

The company has taken up print advertisements recently which has helped increase walk-ins but what they actually need to do is much more – own the category and grow it too. The market size for Car Accessories in India is estimated to be over Rs. 1,000 crore, most of which is unorganized. Car Dealerships and private players like Carnation,3M, etc. have a huge potential, given the shoddy ways of getting your car done up at busy street-side shops. If marketed well, this could be a viable Retail model and is easily scalable. Like in many other cases, I see a bigger opportunity in smaller towns across the country where people take good care of their possessions.

For me, its about making up my mind for a 20K bill – sooner than later, I would be there!

Why Flipkart is not Amazon's competition

My former boss and CEO of indiaplaza.com K. Vaitheeswaran always used to say that the best business model on the internet retail space is perhaps without stocking inventory. In my short stint at this web company, which was also the pioneer of India's ecommerce business with the same name set shop in 1999, I added around 60 vendors in just 6 months who would list their wares-from designer clothing to everyday wear, from watches to wallets and so on. During the late 90s, internet cafes were coming up all around the country. To browse the internet on bulky 17" screens with a dial up connection that would take five minutes or more to connect would cost around Rs. 100/- an hour (and the prices subsequently came down due to increased competition and lower internet rates). Shopping online those days was a novelty - well it continues to remain so still I guess. The early 2000s saw a slew of players come and go and during the last part of the decade saw the emergence of the likes of flipkart.com, myntra.com and many others. These ecommerce companies or etailers stocked merchandise-large warehouses were set-up in the suburbs of cities and mostly internal logistics teams ensured last mile delivery. Most of them were venture funded and blew their investors money on advertising, PR and promotions. Some companies were spending as much as Rs. 1,500 for acquiring a new customer - while there is no global benchmark as such for this purpose, the sum would be recovered from the same customer when he/she spends atleast Rs.6,000/- over time assuming 25% Gross margins. Not an impossible task once the customer is habituated to the internet way of shopping. Sadly, of the 25% Gross margins, what remains is less than 1-2% and that too for smart and successful companies. Most of them, even today are reporting negative margins. Well, for any business it takes time to stabilise. Typically for product retailers, break-even happens between 15-18 months and much earlier for F&B retailers. None of the ecommerce companies in India of sizeable scale and repute are profitable as I write this article. And many of them are on the path to profitability. After burning millions of dollars. The good part is customers have taken up to e-shopping faster than they have taken to Organised Retailing. Retail Industry in India is about Rs. 400,000 crores approximately and less than 10% is fom the Organised Retailers. Led by apparel and fashion, the organised industry is seeing massive growth, at a CAGR of over 15% over the past 6-8 years. Not bad, while global retailers are seeing negative growth on same store growth year onyear. Amidst all this, the $61 Billion Amazon launched its India site in June 2013. Not much different than its previous avatar, Junglee.com which was launched with much fanfare in early 2012. Amazon.in is a marketplace, a business model where retailers, small or big can list their products and Amazon attracts potential customers to shop on its site with secure payment gateways and millions of items listed across its pages. The Amazon trust is expected to attract many more customers and in the short term, Amazon may also build large warehouses and extend direct sales to its customers, subject to Retail FDI regulations. And there has been speculation that sooner than later, Amazon would compete heavily with the likes of Flipkart. Within the online space, perhaps yes but not in the consumption space. The e-tailers have to compete directly with the physical Retailers, both Organized and Unorganized. They are the main competition for the ecommerce companies. Together, Amazon, Fipkart and hundreds of other sites would fuel up consumption using the internet. However, with low penetration of Broadband Internet and 3G on mobile phones, it is unlikely that this retail landscape would change drastically over the next five years. Afterall, half a decade is a long time in business...

Product Vs. Experience

A couple of days back, I was having a conversation with a colleague regarding Brand Experience versus Product specifications. He was of the view that a customer proposes to buy a certain brand or a product but the actual retail experience is utmost important to close the Sale. It got me thinking and the result of some intellectual head-scratching is this column. At the end of the day, it’s the product that the customer is ultimately going to use and may or may not remember the sales experience, especially for low-value items. In fact it may even qualify for certain high value purchases.

For example, Bose which manufactures some of the finest sound systems in the world  advertises heavily online these days (in India), about its products. They are usually banner ads and I find them all across – there is a certain way the online advertisers follow you (which I will cover in a subsequent blog later). But I wonder what kind of experience that Bose is driving while advertising its products online. For one, Bose is not bought. Bose is lived. In a sense that the experience of Bose is something that the consumer lives with during the lifetime of the product. Having said that, would a potential customer walk in to a Bose store after seeing the online ad? Probably yes. Bose banner ads direct the user to the Bose website. It is upto the customer thereafter to seek whatever information they need. And therefore, there is no closure of sale! Is Bose trying to popularise the brand or is it a sales technique? I guess it is the former.

On the other hand, Samsung advertises its most famous Galaxy range of smatphones online too. In this case also, the company is building the brand but the nodes (read Retail touchpoints) for buying the product are umpteen in number than in the case of Bose. For, a Samsung Galaxy is available at thousands of retailers across the country in comparison to a Bose.

While the online ad would build curiosity for a brand like Bose, it would convert more customers for Samsung. And these are just examples.

Read More: The Bose Experience

While at the Retail Store, when a customer intends to buy a mobile phone, irrespective of the store experience, the customer would choose from one of the four main Operating Systems – the Android, the BlackBerry, the Nokia OS and the Apple iOS. It probably wouldn’t matter whether the retail store is Croma or EZone or Reliance Digital or a regional Retailer such as Viveks or Girias or for that matter, small time shops that sell these types of phones. In this case, its just the product that matters and not really the experience. Ecommerce is playing an even more important spoiler for Offline Retailers in terms of snatching away customers. Is there a physical experience in online shopping? Not really. Indeed, there is a lot of science in designing a great website / webpages but that’s more technical. Playing with the layouts is a tried and tested way for online retailers to keep improving the shopping experience. But there is really no “customer experience” as such while shopping online.

There is no doubt that the customer would return to the Retail Store to buy a similar product the next time around if the experience at the store was extraordinary. Therefore it is indeed important for Retailers to ensure a consistent Consumer Experience at the outlets. At the end of the day, between product (availability) and experience, the customer would choose the product.

RIP Musicworld

It was a bright sunny sunday, June 24th 2001 to be precise. I landed in Kolkata in the morning by train at Howrah where my former classmate picked me up at the Railway Station. The smell of freshly procured fishes welcomed me as we passed by the Howrah Bridge over the Ganges in a yellow taxi – the iconic Ambassador which still runs in the city even now. After lunch and a short nap, I walked down Russell Street towards Park Street, the most popular shopping alley in what was then known as Calcutta. At the corner was an iconic orange and purple signage aptly named “music world” – the main branding purposely in small letters to convey the casual attitude of the brand. As I entered the store, I was in for a shocking surprise. Over 8,000 sft of space allotted to music – cassettes and CDs. There were separate areas for different genres of music. At the entry was Hindi and Bollywood – the Bengalis loved hindi film music as much as they loved their own. RD Burman and Kishore Kumar, were afterall local boys who made it big in Bollywood. And so was Amitabh Bachchan who used to roam around Park Street looking for a suitable career over 50 years ago. The influence of Western Music was notable on Bengalis – From Carpentars to Led Zep, from Michael Jackson to Madonna, people here listened to all forms of music. Regional Music – Bengali language was located at the far end of the store along with some titles from other parts of the country such as Tamil, Kannada and Telugu. Rabindrasangeet, the music compositions of Nobel Laureate Rabindranath Tagore sung by various artists had a separate section. This was the largest music store in the country.  And I was going to be managing the store from the next day onwards! Whoa! I was so excited.

Life at MW as it was called was pretty cool. The store would open for business around 10am and would close by 8.30pm as per local government norms. Customers would slowly start trickling in the morning, typically housewives and retired people and a number of NRIs who were on vacation in town. College goers and those who work in offices nearby would peep in during lunch hours before or after having a delicious meal at one of the restaurants on Park Street. Evenings would be college goers and music enthusiasts. In 2001, the store used to clock a sale of Rs. One Lakh per day selling music cassettes worth Rs. 35-55 each. DVDs were slowly growing then, and Video Games were starting to become a rage among the young and old slowly. Need for Speed was the most sold video game of those days. The RPG Group which was the company that owned musicworld launched with much fanfare “Hamara CD”, a kiosk which can create a customised CD of songs from across their extensive catalogue. The concept took off well though the prohibitive price of about Rs. 350/- per CD was too much of an ask and a deterrent to growth. Eventually, it died a natural death.  There were so many album releases and launches almost every other day. It was great interacting with the guests, notably of them included Sourav Ganguly who had come for a music album launch and Diya Mirza who had come to promote her film “Rehna Hai Tere Dil Mein” (RHTDM, which was originaly made in Tamil as Minnale). Artist visits and Launches would culminate with a High Tea at the Flurys next door, one of the oldest and most respected Cakes and Pastries shop in the country. I had a great team to work with and each member knew their job so well. In fact I am still in touch with a couple of them and one of them has stayed back with the same store till date – for over 14 years!

Even during those days, I was of the opinion that music would become free sooner than later. And to promote music, we had to promote music players and alternate sources which could play music. Early 2000s were the time computers were beginning to become a part of our corporate lives. Thick cardboard files were replaced by Floppy Disks carrying 20 times the data and which could fit in easily in a shirt pocket. CDs were just about to be gaining popularity. MP3 was a fairly unheard of format then. I remember discussing in various internal meetings that the company should sell music players along with music Cassettes and CDs. Naturally, as a freshly passed out Management Graduate from a Business School, my pleas fell onto deaf ears. I believed that unless we promoted CD players – the huge decks and portable ones, there was no chance that we were going to sell more CDs. I had already sensed that cassettes would see their end sooner than later and the next big wave was hearing music on computers and laptops. Almost every single senior that I interacted with laughed me off. I also suggested that we entered the Mall way of retailing – Rahul Saraf, the promoter of the first organized Mall in Kolkata, The Forum approached me to discuss a proposal to set-up a MW outlet within. My proposal was beaten down by the Management saying that Calcuttans would not shop at Malls and would rather prefer local markets at Ballygunge or Explanade. MW entered Malls much later but by then, music was already available in various other formats across devices. Sadly, the business declined slowly and it was recently announced that the curtains would permanently come down by the end of June 2013.

I don’t fully agree that piracy alone is the reason for the decline of the Music Industry. It is also because the industry failed to keep up with the technological advancements. I was recently reading on Forbes India about Alok Kejriwal of Games2Win and his Indian experiences when he tried to come up with wonderful ideas in the mobile telephony space. He was the one who successfully pioneered the concept of Caller Tunes in India – one could send an SMS and get a caller tune and have it stored in their mobile phone. As he painfully explains, the mobile operators wanted to charge a premium for the service and also a lions’ share of profits from the venture rather than making the concept popular. Similarly, the Hamara CD could have been a clear winner those days. But the opportunity and greed cost the company quite a bit. Over time, music world eventually started selling non-core items such as MP3 players and the like, but it was too late by then. The kiosk outside the store on Park Street was selling cheaper chinese made MP3 players for a quarter of the price. music world also failed to collaborate with other music labels in the country to come up with alternate ways of streaming music, mainly because they owned the domestic and international rights of the extensive HMV catalogue. In fact, initially HMV owned content would get more prominence in the store than that of other labels.

A couple of years back, I approached music world to co-opt with Café Coffee Day, India’s largest coffee chain with over 1,400 outlets across the country where I was the Head of Business Development and Expansion across the country. Instead of seeing it as a way to garner more footfalls and attract more music enthusiasts into the store, the folks at the company rather tried to charge a premium for space. Obviously the deal didn’t go through. Am sure, the team tried their best to revive the falling business, but what probably lacked was innovation and new ideas, not for the lack of it but for a lack of willingness, probably. It was one of the saddest days in my life when my former colleague informed me about its closure. I always knew this day would come, but it was earlier than expected. RIP Musicworld.

Inviting patrons for a great feast

The Hotel Industry in India is facing tough times ever since the global recession occurred a couple of years ago. In my current role at Royal Enfield as Head of Business Development, I travel atleast 2-3 days every week across the country. Whenever I try to book rooms in small and big cities, the room rates just surprises me. I was trying to look for rooms in Hyderabad for stay over the next few days and was surprised to find discounted rates at 5 star hotels for as low as Rs. 5000 (USD 90). The Leela and Grand Chola – both touted as 7 star rated properties in Chennai are offering over 40% discounts on printed rates, to as low as Rs. 7,000 (USD 130). Same is the case in Delhi, Gurgaon, Mumbai, Pune and is even worse in smaller towns. I stayed in Trichy, a city in central TamilNadu which connects a number of other towns of prominence in business and culture within a 100 km radius during the first week of May 2013. On the MakeMyTrip mobile app for the Apple iPhone, I could get a double room for three adults and two kids for as low as Rs. 2,500 (USD 55). The room was quite large to hold a King size bed and two single beds. I have stayed in cities like Coimbatore, Dehra Dun, Jammu, Patna and many others for similar rates in well maintained properties. The outlook for hospitality in India as such wears a glim look and with increasing inventory and competition, not to forget the choices that customers make, the pricing is aggressive at most of the properties. This is where ancillary income to Hotels are helping them.

Most of the hotels have in-house restaurants, mainly to cater to resident guests. Many of them advertise these restaurants quite heavily, thereby attracting visitors through the year irrespective of peak season or otherwise for room occupancy. While this practice has been there for long, its quite evident these days with a number of hotels including some premium Hotel chains advertising in the media. What caught my attention recently  was an ad (displayed above), by ITC Hotels, one of India’s largest companies in the hospitality space for their Cappuccino Restaurant at the erstwhile Park Sheraton (in Chennai) . They have advertised buffet options with prices! Do those patrons who visit these places really care for the price? I mean – everyone does. But then, do people care what the final bill is gonna be when they visit star rated hotels and restaurants? I really doubt. Restaurant incomes are an important source of revenue for Hotels. They contribute anywhere between 7-25% of total sales depending on how well these restaurants are positioned and popularised. Some of the restaurants in these hotels are even Michelin-rated – a rating by the Vehicle Tyres powerhouse Michelin which grades eating joints across the world and shares in a report that is published annually.

Suggested Reading: Franchising

Stand-alone restaurants are doing their best too, to woo potential customers. They advertise in leading newspapers regularly to attract attention and over a period of time become destinations. In some cases, they are located within hotels and Malls and in many cases they are located on High Streets. User reviews in sites and apps such as Trip Advisor, Zomato, Burrp! etc. help them gain more traction. Chains like McDonalds, Pizza Hut, Subway and Café Coffee Day advertise across the media regularly to pull customers to their outlets and many of them even offer complimentary WiFi as a hook to retain them.

Suggested Reading: Does Free Wifi help?

With inflation leading to peak rates of food items, it is becoming impossible to middle class families to venture out eating outside. But the upper-middle class seems to be slightly more insulated, fuelling the needs of these restaurants. While premium hotels and restaurants promise great food (quality) and a wonderful ambience, consistency is key. To retain existing customers and to attract newer ones. If you are planning a visit to a nearby restaurant this weekend, flip through the pages of newspapers or mobile apps and you may be in for a surprise at a hotel nearby you! Happy Dining…

Suggested Reading: Food Inflation

Shaswat Goenka–Hearlding new frontiers at Spencers Retail

 

After dabbling with various sectors in the Rs 14,000-crore RP-Sanjiv Goenka group for about a year, Shashwat Goenka, 23, son of group chairman Sanjiv Goenka, has taken charge of Spencer's, the retail chain, from April 1. In an interview with Namrata Acharya & Ishita Ayan Dutt of Business Standard, he talks about his personal mandate and the road map for the Rs 1,400 crore business. Edited excerpts:

What goal have you set for Spencer's?
I assumed the role of sector head from April 1. What is most important at this point in time is profitability; that's where we are all trying to go. That will be the focus for the coming year and the year after. Spencer's is aiming to deliver Ebitda (operating earnings) breakeven at a company level in the third quarter of 2013-14 and be Ebitda-positive on a full year basis in 2014-15. That's the overarching short-term goal.

Spencer's has missed its breakeven deadline quite a few times. What makes you think you would be able to achieve it?
Well, each time we have done better. We have achieved breakeven at store-level but company level is what we want to achieve.

How do you plan to get there?
We want to increase our footprint. We will go up to two million sq ft from 900,000 sq ft currently and will expand in the north, east and south over the next four to five years.
We will achieve it over the next few years. The other important thing, obviously, would be operational efficiency.
In terms of offering, we would look at increasing international foods and regional foods. Value-added fresh is one of the areas we would like to explore.

Doesn't the fresh segment have one of the lowest margins?
We have very good margins in the food business compared to our competitors. Margins in apparel are obviously much higher but our margins in foods are good.

Any new formats for Spencer's on the anvil?
We haven't thought of any. We want to grow in hypermarkets.

Is the rationalisation process for Spencer's over?
Last year was the rationalising and consolidation process. We have exited Pune. In the past two years, we have closed 65 stores. Now, we want to start growing and in the hypermarkets.
Earlier, we had hyper, super, daily and express stores. Now, we have hyper and dailies and a few of the old express stores are still functioning.

Why did you exit Pune?
We wanted to become stronger where we are. So, we wanted to focus on the north, south and east. After we get that strong, we will revisit the west.

Why do you think the response from foreign retailers has been muted, after FDI (foreign direct investment) has been cleared?
I think people are interested. They just want to figure it all out before they come in.

Do you see foreign retailers as a threat to Spencer's?
Walmart and its likes coming in will help us. We can learn a lot from them. Back-end infrastructure will improve. There are basic infrastructure issues in India, like roads. Also, cold chains or dairy chains, for instance, are not very well developed.

A lot of options were being explored at the back-end by retailers. Any progress on that front?
We are open to FDI at the back-end but we haven't been approached by anyone.

Spencer's was exploring the IPO (public share offer) option. When is it likely?
That's something we definitely want to do but right now, the focus is on profitability.

Would you look at getting into the cash and carry format?
We have not looked at it. We want to be profitable and then explore other things.